RE: Patch to bfd/aix5ppc-core.c for gdb-6.3 with gcc 4 on AIX5.1

["Rodney Brown" <rbrown@bravurasolutions.com.au>]

gdb-6.3 builds fine with this patch.

I'd reword the comment a little.

!   /* The core_hdr() macro is not used here because it would be
!      casting the LHS of an assignment and some versions of gcc
!      will generate a warning for this.  */ 
 
From http://gcc.gnu.org/gcc-3.4/changes.html

The cast-as-lvalue extension has been removed for C++ and deprecated for
C and Objective-C. In particular, code like this:

        int i;
        (char) i = 5;
        
or this:

        char *p;
        ((int *) p)++;
        
is no longer accepted for C++ and will not be accepted for C and
Objective-C in a future version.

So maybe

The core_hdr() macro is no longer used here because it would
expand to code relying on gcc's cast-as-lvalue extension, removed in gcc
4.0.

Don't know,
Thanks

-----Original Message-----
From: Nick Clifton [mailto:nickc@redhat.com] 
Sent: Monday, 8 August 2005 10:34 PM
To: Rodney Brown
Cc: gdb-patches@sources.redhat.com; binutils@sources.redhat.com
Subject: Re: Patch to bfd/aix5ppc-core.c for gdb-6.3 with gcc 4 on
AIX5.1

Hi Rodney,

> Are you using a gcc 4.1 development compiler?

Yes - but I am not compiling under AIX.  I do not have access to an 
AIX5.1 system, so when I built a cross compiler the build system must 
have left out the core file support.  Silly me.

> I assumed that using the accessor macro was the preferred mechanism.

It is, but when the macro is tied to a single particular function it 
really ought to be defined inside the function.  That way if the code is

ever rearranged it will not be lost.

So - what do you think of the attached, simplified patch ?  If it fixes
the compile time warning then I would be happy to check it in.

Cheers
   Nick